Creatie Review

I’ve come across an exciting new AI tool specifically designed for UI design called Creatie. At first glance, it resembles Figma but includes a few extra AI features. Creatie allows you to import files from Adobe XD, Figma, or Sketch seamlessly. As a seasoned UI/UX designer, I decided to test it out and share my thoughts. Here’s a detailed breakdown of my experience with Creatie.

Product Overview

Creatie’s landing page is sleek and modern, inspiring trust right from the start. The layout is very similar to Figma but with additional AI tools. Let’s dive into the four main features of Creatie:

1. Image Enhancer: This feature doesn’t add much value to my design process, so I am ignoring it in this review.

2. Magicon: This AI-powered tool generates icons based on your prompts. It’s a cool concept, but not always practical for my specific design needs.

3. Wizard: This allows you to select an area and prompt AI to input components. However, it felt more like a component library search rather than true AI functionality.

4. Automatic Style Guide: This feature extracts a style guide from your designs, saving time but lacking customization and true AI integration.

5. Auditor: This tool audits your design based on your design system and best practices. While it’s a neat feature, calling it an AI function is a stretch.

In-Depth Feature Analysis

1. Audit Tool

I tested the Audit tool by importing my design files and found it to be more of a rule-based logic checker than a true AI tool. It offers suggestions on text size, corner radius, and placement but doesn’t provide the AI-driven insights I expected. Plugins like Contrast for Figma can achieve similar results without needing a new platform.

2. Style Guide Extraction

The Style Guide extraction tool is straightforward. It pulls basic design properties and generates a style guide, but again, it lacks the innovation and customization one would expect from an AI tool. Figma’s plugins offer similar functionalities.

3. Wizard Tool

The Wizard tool felt like a glorified search function for pre-existing components rather than a generative AI tool. It could benefit from a more conversational AI approach, asking follow-up questions to refine and tailor the generated components.

4. Magicon

Magicon was the only feature that truly utilized AI, generating unique icons based on prompts. However, achieving the desired result often took multiple attempts, making it less efficient than traditional methods like using Illustrator for specific icon creation.

Migration and Collaboration

Creatie offers easy migration from other design tools and supports collaboration, prototyping, and developer handoff, similar to Figma. However, it falls short by not allowing export back to other platforms like Figma, which can be a dealbreaker for many designers.

Final Thoughts

While Creatie is an impressive clone of Figma with a few added features, it doesn’t offer enough to convince designers to switch from established tools. The AI features are underwhelming and often misrepresented. Migrating to a new tool is a significant commitment, and without substantial benefits, it’s hard to justify.

Conclusion

I’ve tested Creatie so you don’t have to. While it has potential, it’s not quite there yet. If you’re looking for AI-driven tools for icon creation, consider alternatives like Recraft. Stay tuned for more insights on AI tools by subscribing to my newsletter, and don’t forget to check out my latest video on Recraft.

Thanks for reading!